Judicial Review - Legitimate or Made Up?

It's an old debate - what is the basis for the doctrine of judicial review in the United States, and is it a valid one? Here's my offering on the subject. I invite comments from any and all who see this and want to weigh in. The Constitution's text implies judicial review vaguely or not at all. Article III section 2 extends "the judicial power" to "all cases * * * arising under this Constitution," and the second sentence of Article VI makes the Constitution "the supreme law of the land," but evidence from the Constitutional Convention and ratifying conventions does not support that language as a source for judicial review. Madison argued at Philadelphia that Article III specifically does not give the Supreme Court power to invalidate legislation. See Christopher Collier, Decision in Philadelphia (1987) at 269.

It was up to the antifederalist known as Brutus, in his Twelfth Essay, to warn that under the Constitution courts would use arbitrary standards to refuse enforcement to laws they thought were unconstitutional, and (presciently) that the dangerous outcome would be to "give the constitution a construction according to its spirit and reason, and not to confine themselves to its letter." See Ralph Ketcham (ed), The Antifederalist Papers (2003) at 300.

If one argues that the Supreme Court's authority depends upon its being faithful to the spirit as well as the language of the Constitution, one needs to assume there is common agreement on what comprises its unwritten "spirit."  If judicial review is to be performed at all, that highlights the need for a Supreme Court that departs from the Constitution's literal text only in the rarest of cases - to invoke a "spirit" of the Constitution only when the Court is essentially unanimous and even then, as Alexander Bickel wrote, to think of itself as "a court of last resort presumptively only." Alexander Bickel, The Least Dangerous Branch (1962) at 258.

Assuming that an objective "spirit" of the Constitution does exist, and that the word "authority" means the Supreme Court's credibility with the American public, then the Court's fidelity to that spirit is indeed vital to its survival as a respected institution.  Chief Justice Marshall successfully invoked the "spirit" of the Constitution in McCulloch v. Maryland (17 U.S. 316, 421 (1819)) to confirm Congressional authority to charter a national bank.  Justice Harlan was less successful when he invoked a Constitutional "spirit" in his dissent from the majority in Plessy v. Ferguson (163 U.S. 537, 563 (1896)), but the Court vindicated his view 58 years later.

So who wins the debate on judicial review?  In Federalist 78, Alexander Hamilton reasoned that because a constitution must be regarded by judges as fundamental law, and because the Constitution does not authoirze Congress to be the judge of its own powers, it belongs to the judiciary to ascertain the meaning not only of Congressional acts, but also of the Constitution.  Hamilton said it is rational to view the courts as an intermediary between the people and the Congress, to keep Congress within its delegated authority.

Hamilton said it well.  Judicial review lies at the heart of a government of separated powers.  It is, in that most fundamental respect, constitutional.

Comments

[Bwqvvsex]

The National Gallery Free Preteen Pics 87239

[Eqteqxad]

Which team do you support? madthumbs 94495

[Mccvwtmz]

Will I get paid for overtime? Preteen Nudism ruk

[Zymjcanh]

What's the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas? megaporn =]

[Dewvpqgm]

I'm training to be an engineer Preteen Models Bbs 63810

[Ldonsmhf]

I'm unemployed Young Lolita Toplist jzfx

[Erady]

click must have handbags high fashion designer online shopping usa bag for gift

[Caoyjpbf]

We'd like to offer you the job rape gallery links 571692 superheroinecentral rape 94921 lipstick margaux hemingway rape scene >:-[ large cock rape =-[ aniston rape scene :P free real rape pain %-] drugged rape xxx 161727 rape maid free pics :( sexy rape scenes =)) where to report rape =(

[Gifliyzo]

I'm at Liverpool University Lolita Links plny

[Idjhcgpu]

Accountant supermarket manager Lolitas Bbs Pedo 8-]]

[Ggovhreb]

Just over two years Lolita Cum rjw

[Facnzdbm]

I'd like a phonecard, please Lolita Rompl texcz

[Grblvvly]

I really like swimming Russian Preteen >:-PP Preteen Underage 8)) Lolita World 191358

[Fararrgq]

I enjoy travelling Naked Preteens sznyl

[Bpxgjntk]

I read a lot rape the bitch mpegs 8-[[ young rape free zwhxvc bosnian rape stories etoeo Rape in the ass woman 37644 new rape scam email hoax %PP rape porn streaming %-( free daily rape movies 8-))) play rape videos 11527 free hentai rape fantasy 53214 rape of rwandan women 267

[Kvckionr]

Have you seen any good films recently? Lolita Flores 124299 Underage Lolita Porn 9352 Lolitas Underage 147979

[Hedkqoyd]

When can you start? Naked Preteen Toplist %-OO Preteen Galleries gbvkp Preteen Nude Models vrmrwi

[Ivoitiqf]

A few months Lolitas Bbs Pedo tvbllf Preteen Nudity >:-(( Nn Lolita 002

[Waxhwgun]

It's a bad line Preteen Porn Pedo 8] Lolitas Nymphets Rompl 8-((( Lolita Pthc 744

[Sbjxtlaq]

I'd like to take the job Preteen Toplist Xxx =-[[ Preteen Pics %OO Preteen Models Nude 6367

[Zvuhybtv]

I'm sorry, I didn't catch your name Lolita Bbs Topp 100 nbrc Free Lolitas Post Bbs :[[ Lolita Teen Sex Paysite 666 No Nudi Girls Loli =O Free Lolita Nude Site 48740 Cyber Lolita Child Models tfejfu Free Lolita Pic Galleries vocnb Top 10 Pre Lolita :-OOO Free Gallery Lolitas Fuckef 5210 Lilttle Lolitas Non Nude =-PPP

[Egsydfwd]

I'd like some euros Preteen Girl Models %-P Preteen Nonude %)) Off Lolita upjfg

[Sqzcncya]

What company are you calling from? Nn Cuties fos Nn Models Photos :] Nn Model Galleries =)) Young Little Nn Models :) Nn Girl Index iprswf 14 Yo Models Nn 8PPP Nn Model Links 01020 Very Very Young Nn Model Galleries =-PPP Nn Young Pre Lola Models hsjk Nn Little Models =-)))

[Zbljxcsn]

Other amount pretty littlenude lolitas girls jintxc real lolita pay sites 49414 free pic lolita girl 567276 japanese loli image boards fjdibb lolitas teen girls net 277 thai lolita 16 yo qmzc lolita girls thongs pic 8) youngest lolitas nude models 8-) bbs preteen russian lolita =[[ lolita and nymph stories 4917

[Aacqpsfv]

Looking for a job pornos 8-DD