Judicial Review - Legitimate or Made Up?

It's an old debate - what is the basis for the doctrine of judicial review in the United States, and is it a valid one? Here's my offering on the subject. I invite comments from any and all who see this and want to weigh in. The Constitution's text implies judicial review vaguely or not at all. Article III section 2 extends "the judicial power" to "all cases * * * arising under this Constitution," and the second sentence of Article VI makes the Constitution "the supreme law of the land," but evidence from the Constitutional Convention and ratifying conventions does not support that language as a source for judicial review. Madison argued at Philadelphia that Article III specifically does not give the Supreme Court power to invalidate legislation. See Christopher Collier, Decision in Philadelphia (1987) at 269.

It was up to the antifederalist known as Brutus, in his Twelfth Essay, to warn that under the Constitution courts would use arbitrary standards to refuse enforcement to laws they thought were unconstitutional, and (presciently) that the dangerous outcome would be to "give the constitution a construction according to its spirit and reason, and not to confine themselves to its letter." See Ralph Ketcham (ed), The Antifederalist Papers (2003) at 300.

If one argues that the Supreme Court's authority depends upon its being faithful to the spirit as well as the language of the Constitution, one needs to assume there is common agreement on what comprises its unwritten "spirit."  If judicial review is to be performed at all, that highlights the need for a Supreme Court that departs from the Constitution's literal text only in the rarest of cases - to invoke a "spirit" of the Constitution only when the Court is essentially unanimous and even then, as Alexander Bickel wrote, to think of itself as "a court of last resort presumptively only." Alexander Bickel, The Least Dangerous Branch (1962) at 258.

Assuming that an objective "spirit" of the Constitution does exist, and that the word "authority" means the Supreme Court's credibility with the American public, then the Court's fidelity to that spirit is indeed vital to its survival as a respected institution.  Chief Justice Marshall successfully invoked the "spirit" of the Constitution in McCulloch v. Maryland (17 U.S. 316, 421 (1819)) to confirm Congressional authority to charter a national bank.  Justice Harlan was less successful when he invoked a Constitutional "spirit" in his dissent from the majority in Plessy v. Ferguson (163 U.S. 537, 563 (1896)), but the Court vindicated his view 58 years later.

So who wins the debate on judicial review?  In Federalist 78, Alexander Hamilton reasoned that because a constitution must be regarded by judges as fundamental law, and because the Constitution does not authoirze Congress to be the judge of its own powers, it belongs to the judiciary to ascertain the meaning not only of Congressional acts, but also of the Constitution.  Hamilton said it is rational to view the courts as an intermediary between the people and the Congress, to keep Congress within its delegated authority.

Hamilton said it well.  Judicial review lies at the heart of a government of separated powers.  It is, in that most fundamental respect, constitutional.

Comments

[Cayla]

Good for people to know.

[Loans]

Great read.

[Air Jordans]

The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.

[Air Yeezys]

Thank you for the article, I saw after the enlightened, my idea like you, just not good at expression

[Nike Heels]

That's a great blog entry. It gives me some ideas as to what can and should be done for my own aviation client. http://www.nikeheelsboots.net/

[Asics Tiger]

I also think so,Do you think the best in the webnet too? there were a good web for, you don't like, Never mind, much more:if you like, you can see

[MBT Shoes]

We need one to change it now!

[Kaufen Levitra]

EbYzHs It's pleasant sitting at work to distract from it�to relax and read the information written here:))

[carpinteyrocod]

As a French fashion house founded in 1854, LV has improved greatly and acquired countless lovers across the world. Recent years, there established many online Louis Vuitton Sale, aiming at making people¡¯s shopping more convenient. You don¡¯t need to go out of your house and wander about to find the LV Bags you like. Additionally, special discounts of the goods such as Louis Vuitton Purses are offered everyday. Hurry up!
................................................................................
Louis Vuitton Outlet Sale Louis Vuitton Sale

[CL shoes outlet]

May you are hestate to choose a suitable shoes to have a holiday or go to a dancing party? maybe the christianlouboutin is your first choice.love fashion style shoes

[Christian Louboutin]

Sorry,i don't know how to receive my response, why?

Christian Louboutin/Shoes/Sale/Cheap/Outlet/UK/Shop/Store/2011/Online/Discount/

http://www.christianlouboutins-cheap.com/

[carpinteyrotxu]

Abercrombie kids is the younger sibling of abercrombie and fitch. Acheter Abercrombie pas cher en ligne. abercrombie & fitchDeclare abercrombie kids embodies the materially of allocation and East Coast.Messieurs, en vue de l'ouverture du flagship Abercrombie & Fitch a Paris.Abercrombie and Fitch France Officiel Wake up across,jusqu'à 60% moins cher,Les fabricants vendent directement.Nous nous concentrons sur 2011 abercrombie and fitch france.

[carpinteyrowll]

Identitadroit abetting" et qualité de lie down, franklin et marshall confectionne des lignes de vêtements respectueuse de la character universitaire,Vente vetements franklin and marshall Pas Cher Boutiques.

[carpinteyrorac]

Identitpraisefully trained set" et qualité de constructing, franklin et marshall confectionne des lignes de vêtements respectueuse de la academy universitaire,Vente vetements franklin and marshall Pas Cher Boutiques.

[pletcherddy]

Acceptable to our monlcer atypical Moncler corn! There are a stalwart horde of doudoune moncler which more imagine you more charming and elegant. Moncler women's the craze at ShopStyle. Stockpile present stores to learn Moncler women's the latest middleman on sale.

[Nike Free]

Mr Reiss says he has not been surprised by the victims. "People are much more discerning now about how they spend their money and you have to keep moving forward as a brand. If you don't have that sense of uniqueness or give customers what they want, you are going to struggle. You have to be adaptable and understand your customer. It's a tough world out there."

[Christian Louboutin]

Sorry,i don't know how to receive my response, why?

Christian Louboutin/Shoes/Sale/Cheap/Outlet/UK/Shop/Store/2011/Online/Discount/

http://www.christianlouboutinshoes-store.com/

[marmont]

IM43Ng http://www.vX0UUwfbV0BvG3upQKBWlc97t5wQCiD84Bdaq9Om.com

[what is]

This article is a really trustworthy article. Lossing albatross is benificial for your vigorousness and happiness.

[Wuuffxrv]

When can you start? Preteen Nude Pictures :OOO

[BypeEliweeseEbka]

I would like to setup wordpress blog that would allow people to sign up to receive news letters and updates? Do I need to download wordpress to my computer? Is there any pre-made templates for this type?.

[BypeEliweeseEvgk]

My video player in joomla doesn't play videos in firefox if the latest flash player isn't installed. I'd like to have it like a professional player to show a dialog saying: "Do you want to install flash player 10" or how it says when you go to a professional website so users don't have to search and download flash player manually.... . Does anyone know, how to do this?.

[Cwzdxikh]

Insufficient funds egotastic pxo

[Pbuvatcp]

I'm on a course at the moment Preteen Videos 8(

[Tgdbiovm]

We need someone with qualifications Naked Preteen Girls 8-))