A unanimous Ninth Circuit Panel (Fisher, Gould, Bea) has affirmed an injunction issued by District Judge Ancer Haggerty, barring the City of Portland from enforcing an ordinance that permits ejection of disagreeable hecklers from events held in public areas under City-issued permits in public places.
The plaintiff, Edward Gathright, attended events in Pioneer Courthouse Square and Tom McCall Waterfront Park that were sponsored by abortion rights and gay rights advocacy groups. The groups had obtained permits from the City to stage the events. A Portland city ordinance (City Code 20.08.060) makes it "unlawful for any person unreasonably to interfere with a permittee's use of a Park," and Gathright was ejected from the permittees' events for disrupting them by variously calling abortion rights supporters "whores," "sluts," and "prostitutes," or wearing a t-shirt at a gay rights rally reading, "Got AIDS Yet?"
Gathright challenged his evictions on First Amendment grounds. The City defended its ordinance as a legitimate "time, place, or manner" regulation of protected speech. The Ninth Circuit's opinion Here rejects the City's argument and invalidates the ordinance on its face, distinguishing the Supreme Court's seminal case for such regulation in city parks (Ward v. Rock Against Racism, 491 US 781) and the Supreme Court case most closely on point (Hurley v. Irish-American GLB Group of Boston, 515 US 557), and then concluding without much more discussion that the City's ordinance is not "narrowly tailored" enough to protect the permittees' interest in exercising their right to gather peaceably in city parks.
COMMENT: It seems the Ninth Circuit panel could have given a more thorough analysis of the time, place, or manner regulation of the protected speech in this case. The Supreme Court has held that time, place, or manner regulation is not a prior restraint (Frisby v. Schultz, 487 US 474, 481), meaning that the First Amendment is simply not implicated where the standard is met. A more detailed inquiry into the City's reasons for enactment of its ordinance (did violent confrontations, intimidation of peaceful citizens, or damage to City property, prompt action by the City Council?) would have lent more weight to the Ninth Circuit's result. Or it might have led to a different result.
The chance for greater publicity in a federal forum may explain Mr. Gathright's resort to the First Amendment, but one wonders why he didn't challenge the ordinance under the more speech-friendly Oregon Constitution, Article I section 8. It's apparent from the recent City of Nyssa v. Dufloth, 339 Or 330, 338-339 that "time, place, or manner" regulation of speech is as unconstitutional in Oregon as naked (sorry) prohibition of the speech itself.
If the City of Portland decides to take this case up on certiorari, it should be interesting to watch the Supreme Court's response. Would anyone like to handicap the chances of a grant of cert? Of still another reversal of a "liberal" Ninth Circuit decision?
If I had a tale that I could tell you, I'd tell a tale sure to make you smile;If I had a wish that I could wish for you I'd make a wish for sunshine all the while.
Posted by: coach wallets | July 02, 2010 at 11:38 PM
Business underlies everything in our national life, including our spiritual life, Witness the fact that in the Lord's prayer the first petition is for daily bread, No one can worship God or love his neighbor on an empty stomach. Very reasonable!Post by Jordan Flipsyde
Posted by: Jordan Flipsyde | July 29, 2010 at 11:58 PM
It's distinct to be drank! The centre has some israeli effect. Top class is one famous visita. A proud woman overheard the member factually. I changed that society upon the role.
Posted by: Retro Jordans | September 06, 2010 at 05:26 PM
that maybe emotion-arousing the free speech in the park.
Posted by: wholesaledunk | September 16, 2010 at 02:29 AM
If you'd make a guy content, will not add to his possessions but subtract from his needs. Did you concur with me?
Posted by: Nike Vandal | September 26, 2010 at 06:13 PM
Happiness is a thankful heart, a healthy body, the work of a heart, a love your lover, a trusted friend to help, I wish you all! Through the long time, count fragrant memories, please remember me, like I always think of you.
Posted by: Asics shoes | September 26, 2010 at 11:47 PM
Great article though so thanks it's very interesting you did lot of research before posting any new content.
Posted by: moncler jeackets | September 28, 2010 at 07:25 PM
Thank you for sharing your stuff on blog. It is doubtless that we have similar interests. Something are very helpful to me.
Posted by: air jordans | October 29, 2010 at 08:53 PM
The sum of behaviour is to retain a man’s own dignity, without intruding upon the liberty of others.
Posted by: Air Jordans | October 31, 2010 at 05:28 PM
The each post of your blog is defintely outstanding!I enjoys your blog quite a lot and at the same time,I really appreciate your writing style. WISH YOU HAPPY AND BEAUTY EVERYDAY.
Posted by: air jordans | November 01, 2010 at 05:57 PM
Yes. it is good. Now they are a city of trees.We are seeking the most beautiful city.If I was a city, were you the soul of me?I know your city.I shall wait for the morning and wake up to see thy city in the light.
Posted by: UGG Sundance Grab Handbag | November 02, 2010 at 05:24 PM
Wherever Everyone has the life,But not everyone understand life, cherish life. Don't understand life people, The life to him, it is a kind of punishment. So we must love our life.
Posted by: supra shoes | November 04, 2010 at 08:41 PM
Treat other people as you hope they will treat you!
Posted by: cheap air yeezy | November 05, 2010 at 02:32 AM
Green Leaf is excellent, imo.
Posted by: air jordan | November 11, 2010 at 11:22 PM
That love, not time, heals all wounds?
Posted by: air yeezys | November 12, 2010 at 07:13 PM
Wow, you've got some great stuff.
Posted by: supra footwear | November 17, 2010 at 07:09 PM
mai yifu zai taobao wang shang mian mai hen fangbian, hen shihui keyi tiaodao ziji xihuan de kuanshi.
Posted by: Louis Vuitton Bags | November 23, 2010 at 05:34 PM
It was a pleasure for me to read an article like this, I am very happy :)... Thanks for sharing the information with us, please ask them to continue getting more blogs and articles equally, or at least similar to this!
Posted by: Link building | November 23, 2010 at 10:04 PM
Happiness is intrinsic, it's an internal thing
Posted by: Shox OZ | January 12, 2011 at 12:29 AM
Great comparison between Gathright v. City of Portland, all points were really very helpful to me as I keep looking for on payday loans advice, thanks again.
Posted by: payday loans advice | January 12, 2011 at 01:30 PM
I say these permits are to be limited between the stations. It must also depend on the type of vehicle being used.
Posted by: instant payday loan | January 14, 2011 at 02:53 AM
This is a nice article written.
We see in the oregon and the city of Portland, where free speech is well demonstrated and publicly accepted. However, affirming this unanimously is something really great, for which it should be appreciated.
Thanks for sharing this.
Posted by: Law | January 30, 2011 at 08:20 AM
Your third resource is confidence: repeat the process and stack the feeling of confidence on to happiness and strength!
Posted by: juicy couture store | February 14, 2011 at 09:55 PM
Such a good writing, or by I saw for the first time. I'm quite happy, you are a good writer
Posted by: Air Yeezy | March 22, 2011 at 11:27 PM
Thank you for the article, I saw after the enlightened, my idea like you, just not good at expression
Posted by: Nike Heels | March 22, 2011 at 11:33 PM